Advocates demand end to extra-billing, upset over $15.9 million federal claw back

May 1, 2018


BC Health Coalition present symbolic $15.9 million invoice to private clinics

May 1, 2018

For immediate release 

Vancouver and Kelowna, BC – Today, health care workers, seniors and other public health care supporters presented a symbolic $15.9 million invoice to False Creek Surgical Centre in Vancouver and the Okanagan Surgical Health Centre in Kelowna on behalf of the public. 

Both clinics are suspected to be two of the many BC private clinics unlawfully extra-billing patients. [1] [2]

Extra-billing is an unlawful practice where doctors or private clinics charge a patient for a health care service that should be provided at no cost because it is publicly insured as necessary care.

When extra-billing occurs in a province/territory, the federal government claws back an equivalent amount from the health transfer money sent to that province/territory. This is one of the enforcement measures the federal government uses to uphold the Canada Health Act. The BC government recently announced that the federal government clawed back $15.9 million in health funding from B.C. this year.

The $15.9 million was the estimated amount of extra-billing in BC this year, based on the audits of four clinics (3 audits completed for the year 2015-2016 and an earlier audit). [3] If BC does not stop the unlawful extra-billing, there may be more fines to come.

“We are here to send a clear message that unlawful extra-billing at the expense of patients in need, and the public purse, will no longer be tolerated in B.C.,” said Nat Lowe, BC Health Coalition organizer. “Our ask is that all private clinics in BC who are currently extra billing patients stop breaking the law at the expense of patients and public funds.”

“With the growth of private clinics and the lack of the enforcement of extra-billing in this province, BC has some of the longest diagnostic and surgical wait times in Canada. The government’s new strategy to complete thousands more surgeries and diagnostic tests in the public system is one step in the right direction,” said Rick Turner, BC Health Coalition co-chair.

“With the recent announcement to bring the full Medicare Protection Amendment Act into force and crack down on private clinics who extra bill, the current provincial government is taking responsibility to ensure private clinics are not unlawfully extra billing patients,” Edith MacHattie, BC Health Coalition co-chair. “This is great news for patients and our public health care system.”





Legislation will prohibit payment for blood and plasma collection

April 26, 2018

Screen Shot 2018-04-26 at 12.24.43 PM

Screen Shot 2018-04-26 at 12.24.54 PM

Health Minister Adrian Dix today introduced the Voluntary Blood Donations Act, which will help preserve the integrity of Canada’s public blood and plasma collection system by preventing payment for blood and plasma collection in British Columbia.

“Our voluntary blood donation system is an integral resource that helps saves lives thanks to people who graciously donate,” said Dix. “We are taking action to prevent payment for blood and plasma collection, and to make sure that the donations people give benefit people in our province and Canada.”

No paid plasma collection clinics are operating in British Columbia. This legislation is meant to prevent such operations from being established, by making it illegal to pay, offer to pay, or advertise that they will pay someone for blood or plasma. This is similar to legislation in Alberta, Ontario and Québec.

Currently in Canada, there are private for-profit organizations paying individuals for plasma, and then selling that plasma on the global market. By preventing these businesses from operating in B.C., this legislation will ensure that blood and plasma collected in B.C. stay as part of the national supply system run by Canadian Blood Services (CBS). As the national blood and plasma supplier, CBS is exempt from the legislation, as are the provincial government and medical researchers.


“This is an issue that is very important to me and people around B.C.,” said Judy Darcy, Minister of Mental Health and Addictions. “Our government stands with public health care, and that means keeping the blood supply system a public resource.” Read more »

Report on the Health Sciences Association Conference – April 2018

April 24, 2018

Edward Staples

Edward Staples, President of SOHC (Support Our Health Care) and BC Rural Health Network Lead.

Vancouver Hyatt Regency April 13, 2018 

Achieving High-Performing Primary and Community Care: the Critical Role of Health Science Professions 

The conference opened with a welcome from Val Avery, Health Sciences Association (HSA) President and a First Nations Welcome from Coast Salish Elder Roberta Price. 

The keynote speaker was the Honourable Judy Darcy, BC Minister of Mental Health and Addictions. She gave a brief overview of her first 9 months in office and made the following points: 

• collaboration and team building on the “front lines” is critically important to address the opioid crisis 

• addressing the crisis will require “all hands on deck” 

• the focus of the Ministry is on child and youth prevention, First Nations, and the high rate of death associated with substance use

  • most people who die from opioid overdose die alone 
  • 3 out of 4 are male between the age of 30 and 59
  • 1 in 10 are indigenous 

• problems with the current system:
• “no coordination of services”
• gaps in the service – fragmentation  lack of a team approach
• the goal is to develop an “ask once” system that will take you where you need to go  Read more »

A welcome second chance for BC Medicare protection

April 11, 2018
 FILE PHOTO - Seth Klein is B.C. director of the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives. PNG

FILE PHOTO – Seth Klein is B.C. director of the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives. PNG

This article points out a few aspects that are not often talked about.

For every dollar of extra billing by a private for profit clinic, the federal government claws back an equal amount from its cash transfers. In 2015-16, that amount was $15.9 million, enough for 53,000 MRIs.

So effectively, we all pay for the extra billing.

(Cash transfers are the payments that every province and Territory receives from the Federal government for health care.)

B.C. is the only province that Ottawa has repeatedly fined for unlawful extra billing.

I believe that there is a misconception that private companies will be forced to close; this is incorrect, they can continue to operate as long as they follow the law.

Charter challenge issues strike at the heart of the principles of Medicare

April 10, 2018
Public unions hold a march in support of medicare - Brian McInnis

Public unions hold a march in support of medicare – Brian McInnis




A charter challenge case that could very well affect how health care is delivered in Canada resumes in British Columbia this week.

Dr. Brian Day, CEO of a for-profit surgery clinic, is challenging the ban on extra billing and the use of private insurance for publicly insured services under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, alleging that these laws infringe on a person’s right to defend their body.

Make no mistake. This case is about profit. Profit for doctors, profit for private clinics and profit for insurance companies. 

First, it is no coincidence that Dr. Day began this case after his clinic was audited and found in contravention of the B.C. Medicare Protection Act. Instead of paying back the money he gained through illegal billing, he decided to put medicare on trial.

Second, Dr. Day points to wait lists as evidence patients need the right to seek private care. However, that right already exists. Doctors can opt out of the public system and patients are free to pay the price for private service. What does not exist is the right to charge patients more than the public fee while at the same time collecting the public fee from the province. Using private insurance to pay the extra fees is also not allowed by law. In other words, it is against the law to use the public purse to subsidize private profits. Read more »

Message from the Canadian Health Coalition

April 8, 2018

“On Monday, the Cambie court case resumes in British Columbia and it seeks to overturn the ban on private for-profit health care. This case will likely to end up in the Canada’s Supreme Court and threaten our entire public health care system.

The Canadian Health Coalition is calling on people to stand up & pressure Brian Day to drop the case.

Can you take 30 seconds to help us amplify pressure?

  1. Add your social media to our launch by clicking here:…/69319-put-patients-before-prof…

Using this tool (Thunderclap), public health supporters will post on Facebook & Twitter in unison & dominate coverage

Thunderclap only has permission to share this 1 post via FB & Twitter & can’t access anything else. 

2) Add your name to our letter:

Please ask others in your organization to add their social media too. The more people who sign up, the bigger the audience, and the larger our impact will be on the way Cambie case gets covered — and ultimately its outcome.”

Screen Shot 2018-04-08 at 11.10.02 AM

BC Minister of Health to enforce Medicare Protection Amendment Act

April 4, 2018


Health Minister Adrian Dix said individuals with an income of $15,000 have been paying $300 a year while those earning up to $30,000 have spent $600 on prescription-drug deductibles. As of Jan. 1, 2019, they will no longer pay any deductibles. JOSHUA BERSON/HANDOUT NDP / PNG

Adrian Dix, Minister of Health 


The following is a news release issued by the Ministry of Health, April 4, 2018:

In addition to increasing access to surgeries and MRIs, the Government of British Columbia is bringing into force outstanding sections of the Medicare Protection Amendment Act, 2003, to further support patients and strengthen B.C.’s public health-care system, Adrian Dix, Minister of Health, announced today.

“I am taking action today to protect our public health-care system, and to correct the previous government’s failure to enforce the law, something done at the expense of patients,” said Dix.

The Medicare Protection Amendment Act, 2003, which enhances authority around extra billing, was passed in 2003, but some sections were not brought into force. Currently, the Medical Services Commission can audit practitioners and clinics, and can seek a court-ordered injunction to stop the practice of extra billing, but other actions are limited.

Extra billing means charging a patient or a representative for health care that should be provided at no cost, because it is covered under the Medical Services Plan (MSP), or publicly funded as a benefit under the Hospital Insurance Act.

During 2017-18, the Ministry of Health audited three private clinics. Based on these audits, as well as a previous one, Health Canada estimated that extra billing in B.C., in violation of the Canada Health Act, for the 2015-16 fiscal year, was $15.9 million. In March 2018, federal health funding to B.C. was reduced by this amount. Read more »


To become a member of SOHC, please
email the secretary.
Annual membership is $2.

SOHC Discussion Paper

Developing an Improved and Sustainable Health Care Model for Princeton, B.C
Support Our Health Care has released a discussion paper in order to get feedback from the community, politicians and professionals about the state of local healthcare and what the long term solutions should be.
Download PDF Here